Home / Opinion / Homelessness ~ The Flip Side

Homelessness ~ The Flip Side

This is a reprint from a newsletter I like to read. I find it fitting this morning, also why I feel a personal urgency to become more hands on rather than turning a blind eye. Sometimes I wish that I could crawl back in my semi truck, turn on a great audio book and drive! Pretending none of this is happening in Siskiyou County or the Pacific Northwest for that matter. I laugh inside when I hear someone say, “I miss the good old days.” Yea Me TOO!

โ€œIn a surge of legal briefs [in recent weeks], frustrated leaders from across the political spectrum, including the liberal governor of California and right-wing state legislators in Arizona, charged that homeless encampments were turning their public spaces into pits of squalor, and asked the Supreme Court to revisit lower court decisions that they say have hobbled their ability to bring these camps under controlโ€ฆ 

โ€œFive years ago, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in [a] case from Boise, Idaho, that it was unconstitutional for cities to clear homeless camps and criminally charge campers unless they could offer adequate housing. In the nine Western states covered by the circuit, that ruling has since prompted billions of dollars of public spending on homelessnessโ€ฆ More than 50 governments and organizations asked the high court [last] month to overturn the Ninth Circuitโ€™s recent decisions.โ€ 

New York Times

In addition, โ€œMayor Eric Adams is seeking to suspend New York Cityโ€™s longstanding obligation to provide shelter to anyone who asks for it, as officials struggle to find housing for thousands of migrants arriving from the southern borderโ€ฆ Mr. Adams asked a judge to allow the city to put aside its legal obligation to provide shelter to single adults, arguing in court that the city should be able to temporarily lift the mandate during an emergency.โ€ 

New York Times

Forum Discussions – See most recent comments
https://demo.theflipside.io/forum/

Homelessness is a nation issue, I feel the Boise Act has merits but also has created a lot of other problems for Siskiyou County and the north state.

Jay Martin DBA Siskiyou News Network
From the Left
The left argues that policymakers should focus on providing housing, and generally opposes suspending New York Cityโ€™s right to shelter.
โ€œThere are many ways for local governments to reduce homelessness โ€” primarily building new housing, providing mental health or substance use services and adopting policies that prevent people from becoming homeless in the first place. Citing and arresting homeless people camped on sidewalks, however, is not one of themโ€ฆ 

โ€œItโ€™s a bad idea to invite the Supreme Court to weigh in on homelessness policy, and it isnโ€™t even necessary. Current rulings do not stop city and state officials from getting homeless people out of encampments, or from providing the temporary and permanent housing and services that are the only way to reduce homelessness. They also donโ€™t block limited enforcement as long as there are some places that homeless people can sleep outside or some available shelterโ€ฆ 

โ€œIn Los Angeles, homeless people already are barred from camping in front of schools, day-care centers, parks and other areas designated by council members. They are prohibited from sleeping in vehicles overnight on some streets. Instead of complaining about not having enough ways to force homeless people off sidewalks, officials should be concentrating on finding more housing and offering more services.โ€
Editorial Board, Los Angeles Times

โ€œFor all the failures of the cityโ€™s shelter system, in the four decades since the mandate was enacted, tens of thousands of people have been kept off city streets. A Staten Island judge recently referred to the mandate as a โ€˜relic,โ€™ but it is among the reasons (along with the weather) that New Yorkโ€™s streets donโ€™t resemble those of Los Angeles, where nearly 50,000 people are living on the streets. By comparison, the number of people who live on the streets of New York is estimated at just over 4,000โ€ฆ 

โ€œNew Yorkers should be aware that suspending the right to shelter would put this significant achievement at risk. Also at risk would be the cityโ€™s quality of life, its economy and, principally, the lives and dignity of the thousands of vulnerable people who may be forced to live on the streets if the cityโ€™s legal obligation to shelter them is lifted. Their presence on the streets could also affect businesses and tourism in New York, from restaurants and Broadway to efforts by large corporations to coax workers back to Manhattan offices.โ€
Mara Gay, New York Times

Some argue, โ€œA right to shelter [crowds] out better solutions, starving resources from other approaches to address housing instability. Increasingly, evidence is demonstrating the success of community-based homelessness prevention efforts that seek to resolve the issues that lead to evictionโ€ฆ

โ€œOther promising solutions can be found in efforts to provide short-term rental assistance rather than shelter, and in so-called supportive housing programs, in which people are given at-home attention to help them maintain housing stabilityโ€ฆ If forced to fund a bloated shelter system, public resources remaining for real solutions are starved.โ€
Linda Gibbs, New York Times
From the Right
The right argues that policymakers should focus on treating mental health and substance abuse, and that New York City should suspend its right to shelter.
โ€œThe misguided notion that providing free housing with no strings attached would solve homelessness has been debunked time and time again. Cities like Austin have seen a surge in homelessness, despite liberal policies aimed at providing housing. What these cities fail to address is the underlying issue โ€“ that homelessness is more often a problem of addiction and mental illness than it is of housingโ€ฆ 

โ€œSan Franciscoโ€™s move toward requiring drug testing and treatment is a step in the right direction, mirroring similar policy shifts we’ve seen in other parts of the country. It acknowledges a brutal truth that many on the left would rather ignore: that you can’t heal someone by merely putting a roof over their head; you have to treat the root cause of their sufferingโ€ฆ 

โ€œCritics argue that this new policy is punitive or inhumane, but what is truly inhumane is allowing people to continue living in squalor and addiction without interventionโ€ฆ Itโ€™s time to replace empty virtue signaling with effective policy.โ€
Chuck DeVore, Fox News

โ€œโ€˜Beginning in the early 1980s, studies consistently began to report that approximately one-third of the homeless population was affected by schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, bipolar disorder, or major depression. By the late 1990s, people with serious mental illness were reported to be 10 to 20 times more likely than the general population to become homelessโ€™โ€ฆ

โ€œ[In addition] The federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has reported that at least a third engage in substance abuse. But here, too, one cannot overlook liberal policy preferences. In promoting the legalization of โ€˜recreational marijuana,โ€™ liberals have effectively normalized drug use as part of daily lifeโ€ฆ 

โ€œThe [CDC] estimated 3 in 10 marijuana users develop โ€˜marijuana use disorder,โ€™ including a need to use increasing amounts for the same effect, and that 10% become outright addictedโ€ฆ 

โ€œIn effect, the city and perhaps the states appealing the Boise ruling are in the early stages of reconstituting a mental health treatment systemโ€ฆ Truly addressing the reasons for street homelessness, however, will require liberal cities and states to undertake major course corrections toward involuntary commitment, discouraging drug use, and understanding that housing costs are not the reasons for homeless encampments.โ€
Howard Husock, Washington Examiner

โ€œDuring the dark days of New Yorkโ€™s decline from the 1960s through the early 1990s, its leaders routinely pinned blame not on their own decisions or the cityโ€™s structural shortcomings, but on insufficient help from Albany and Washington. Mayor Adams has a choice to make. He can continue to do what clearly hasnโ€™t worked, pleading for money that will wind up in a bottomless pit of homeless-shelter contracts. Or he can accept a bad situation for what it is, shoulder responsibility for his role in managing it, and make the hard decision to scrap the right to shelter.โ€
John Ketcham, City Journal

SHARE with 1 friend today
https://sparklp.co/c465c732/


  • CALFIRE SISKIYOU UNIT HAND CREW SELECTED FOR BLUE RIBBON AWARD
    Post Views: 17 YREKA โ€“ The Blue Ribbon Award was created by the Western Fairs Association, the premier organization dedicated to supporting and promoting the fair industry in the Western United States and Canada, to honor those that go above and beyond to support their annual fair.  The 10th District Agricultural Association Board of Directors,
  • 10th DAA selects Kenny Elwood for 2026 Golden Pass
    Post Views: 14 YREKA- The 10th District Agricultural Association Board of Directors is happy to announce a Lifetime Pass will be presented to Kenny Elwood of Bella Vista. The pass will be given at the opening ceremonies of the Siskiyou Golden Fair on June 24th.  Opening ceremony begins at 5:00 PM at the fairground flagpole
  • FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT: Carson’s Window Coverings & More
    Post Views: 18 Filing No.: 2026-47-0190FILED IN: Siskiyou CountyDATE: 06-03-2026Laura Bynam, ClerkBy: D.Brooks,Deputy ClerkFICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENTThe following person (persons) is (are) doing business as:Carson’s Window Coverings & More108 S. BroadwayYreka, CA 96097 in SiskiyouMailing Address:108 S. BroadwayYreka, CA 96097530 598-9247Registered Owner(s):Maridee CarsonThis Business is conducted by: An IndividualThe registrant commenced to transact business under
  • Traffic Stop in Siskiyou County Leads to $1.9 Million Cocaine Seizure, Driver Arrested
    Post Views: 32 Source – Siskiyou County Sheriff’s Office -$1.9 Million Cocaine Seizure Results in Arrest- On May 29, 2026 at approximately 1150 hours, a Siskiyou County Deputy conducted a traffic stop on a 2022 Mazda CX5 for a mechanical violation. During the traffic stop, the driver was found to be unlicensed and demonstrating multiple
  • F-35A Lightning II Jets from Luke AFB Arrive for Two-Week Training at Kingsley Field
    Post Views: 19 Siskiyou County, California โ€” Residents in Siskiyou County and surrounding areas may notice increased jet activity and noise in the skies over Shasta Valley and nearby regions as a squadron of advanced F-35A Lightning II fighters from Luke Air Force Base, Arizona, trains with the Oregon Air National Guardโ€™s 173rd Fighter Wing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *