BY DAN WALTERS
CalMatters
Cover photo: Gov. Gavin Newsom discusses his initial 2024-25 budget proposal at the Secretary of State Auditorium in Sacramento on Jan. 10, 2025. Photo by Miguel Gutierrez Jr., CalMatters
In summary
California faces the prospect of ongoing, multibillion-dollar gaps for the remainder of Gavin Newsom’s term as governor. Will he solve the underlying problems or leave them for his successor?
California governors tend to leave hefty budget deficits behind when they depart, forcing their successors to raise taxes, borrow money or make big spending cuts to maintain solvency.
It happened in 2003 when Democrat Gray Davis was recalled and Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger succeeded him, and again in 2011 when Schwarzenegger handed over the governorship to Democrat Jerry Brown, to cite two recent examples.
The current governor, Democrat Gavin Newsom, was spared when he assumed office in 2019. However, having increased spending by nearly 50% over the last five years, Newsom now faces not only a huge deficit – the exact size is subject to debate – but the prospect of multibillion-dollar shortfalls for the remainder of his governorship.
Late last year, the Legislature’s budget analyst, Gabe Petek, issued his annual report on the state’s fiscal situation, saying not only that state had a $68 billion current deficit due to revenues falling short of projections, but annual deficits in the $30 billion range for the next several years.
Last week, when Newsom proposed a 2024-25 budget, he pegged the deficit at $38 billion and proposed to cover it with a mixture of spending cuts and deferrals, loans from special funds, reserves and some accounting gimmicks.
Over the weekend, Petek reiterated his estimate of a larger deficit and once again told the Legislature that it should take a longer-range view – not only closing the current gap but addressing the structural deficit that lies ahead.
“Overall, the governor’s budget runs the risk of understating the degree of fiscal pressure facing the state in the future,” Petek said in a review of Newsom’s proposal. “The Legislature likely will face more difficult choices next year. To mitigate these challenges, we recommend the Legislature develop this year’s budget with a focus on future years.”
While Newsom and Petek’s disagreement is mostly due to revenue estimates and school finance obligations, they agree that the deficit isn’t a one-time problem, but rather an ongoing gap between likely revenues and spending already locked into law.


A little-noticed section of Newsom’s budget, projecting income and outgo through 2027-28, says it would be an eye-popping $81 billion out of balance by then, largely due to fairly stagnant revenues being outstripped by mandatory increases in spending for K-12 schools and community colleges, and complete exhaustion of reserves.
This gloomy fiscal outlook also assumes that the state won’t experience a recession in the next few years. Were that to occur, the annual deficits would surely be even larger.
The longer-term projections indicate that Newsom’s approach – papering over the current shortfall with actions that could worsen future problems – is very shortsighted, and Petek’s advice to legislators about focusing on the future is quite prudent.
However, Petek’s approach would require Newsom and a legislature dominated by Democrats to make some very difficult decisions, such as throttling back the extensive array of new and expanded social services they have enacted in recent years and/or raising taxes.
The difficulty is compounded by Newsom’s current obsession with building a national political profile, perhaps in preparation for a 2028 presidential run. He has been peddling the image of California as a state that is generous with benefits without increasing its already high level of taxation, specifically opposing those in his party who want to increase taxes on the wealthy or corporations.
The projections by Petek and Newsom’s own budget advisors of ever-increasing deficits undercut that image. Will Newsom bite the bullet or muddle through the next few years and dump a huge fiscal crisis on his successor?
Dan Walters OPINION COLUMNIST
Dan Walters has been a journalist for more than 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times… More by Dan Walters
Members make “it” possible.
- Northstate Youth Protect Los Angeles Waterways from Post-Fire ContaminationThe California Conservation Corps has local youth from Northstate responding as part of the state’s largest watershed protection mission. By Chris Van Horne Parker Robertson, a young adult from the Northstate, is part of a massive response to protect the burned areas of Los Angeles from taking another hit. This time from winter storms. “Watershed… Read more: Northstate Youth Protect Los Angeles Waterways from Post-Fire Contamination
- Fairchild MC Announces New Technology – working towards the goalBY, Michael MaddenAssistant AdministratorFairchild Medical Center Fairchild Medical Center attended a neonatal resuscitation training in January and was instructed on Fairchild’s new laryngoscope equipped with a screen. The team above, led by Maria Foster, Assistant Manager of OB, are all working towards the goal of delivering excellent maternal and neonatal services. Fairchild also received training… Read more: Fairchild MC Announces New Technology – working towards the goal
- SCSO Cold Case Unit Reopens 1991 Homicide CaseThe Siskiyou County Sheriff’s Office (SCSO) is requesting the public’s assistance in solving a 1991 homicide of Maye Elma Mechling, aged 77, found shot to death at her home in Klamath River, CA. Through their renewed investigative effort, the Cold Case Unit has identified multiple persons of interest. We are requesting the public come forward… Read more: SCSO Cold Case Unit Reopens 1991 Homicide Case
- Red Scarf Society for the Performing Arts Presents JACEK MYSINSKISunday, March 2, 2025, 1 PM Jacek Mysinski is an internationally recognized concert pianist, teacher, composer, and creative project collaborator. Jacek is a pianist with the American Ballet Theatre, New York City and will perform works by Chopin, Debussy, Schumann, Szymanowski, Tchaikovsky and Desyatnikov. Event Details: Ticket Information: Tickets Available at: Event Sponsors:Dr. Christal DuncanBlair… Read more: Red Scarf Society for the Performing Arts Presents JACEK MYSINSKI
- Nation of Jubilation: A Night at the Nightclub Fundraiser with Allison Scull & Victor MartinJoin us for an enchanting evening of acoustic jazz soul music as acclaimed North State performers Allison Scull & Victor Martin bring their unique musical artistry to the Open Sky Gallery. This special fundraising event for Open Sky Gallery promises an intimate evening of exceptional music, fine refreshments, and exciting auction opportunities. Saturday, March 1st… Read more: Nation of Jubilation: A Night at the Nightclub Fundraiser with Allison Scull & Victor Martin