OPINION: Outsiders love bashing California but residents are souring on the state, too

CalMatters
January 19, 2024

By Dan Walters

As Republican presidential candidates were slogging through Iowa and talking to voters prior to this week’s caucuses, California-bashing was common.

Los Angeles Times reporter Seema Mehta picked up on the phenomenon, writing that “the Golden State, its elected leaders and its policies were a constant target.”

“Bashing California, one of the most liberal states in the nation, is a grand tradition in the GOP,” Mehta observed. “But Republican presidential candidates may be targeting the state and its politicians more this cycle because they are a better target than President Biden.”

“Biden isn’t as motivating a villain as other Democrats might be. So the Republican candidates are essentially running a negative campaign against California,” California politics scholar Dan Schnur told Mehta. “The very worst thing Ron DeSantis could think of to say about Nikki Haley during the debate was that she might be more liberal than (Gov.) Gavin Newsom. For an Iowa Republican – or any Republican for that matter – that’s an absolutely terrifying concept.”

California may be the state that many in the rest of the nation loves to hate, but a new poll of Californians indicates that they aren’t very sanguine about the state, either.

The UC Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies found that just 33% of California voters believe the state is headed in the right direction while 57% say it’s on a negative track.

“This is a somewhat more negative assessment than voters have given in similar measures conducted over the past 11 years,” poll director Mark DiCamillo said.

The sour attitudes extend to Newsom, the poll found. Asked about his job performance, 47% of voters surveyed disapprove and 46% approve. That’s a very slight improvement from the 49% to 46% ratio that pollsters found in October.

“However, similar to the October survey, twice as many voters say they strongly disapprove of the governor’s performance (33%) as strongly approve (17%),” DiCamillo noted.

The poll introduced a new topic – the whopping budget deficit that Newsom and the Legislature must address this year – and discovered that nearly 90% of voters consider it a serious issue and there’s almost no support (13%) for raising taxes to deal with it. Instead, voters prefer that Newsom and legislators cut spending (51%) or tap into state reserves (35%) to cover the deficit, which Newsom pegs at $38 billion but the Legislature’s budget analyst estimates to be $68 billion.

Newsom also has shunned raising taxes, but progressive legislators, with support from groups dependent upon the state budget, such as public employee unions, have continued to press for higher personal and corporate income taxes and/or a new tax on wealth.

It appears that by cutting or postponing some spending, using reserves, borrowing from special funds and implementing some accounting gimmicks, the governor and the Legislature could fashion a 2024-25 budget without new taxes.

However, Newsom’s budget advisors and those of the Legislature also agree that California faces continued multibillion-dollar deficits for the next several years, at least, which means the debate over spending cuts and taxes will continue for the remainder of Newsom’s governorship.

“The survey suggests little appetite for tax increases to address the deficit, but a challenge for Governor Newsom and the Legislature is that while spending cuts, in principle, are relatively popular, that support would likely dissipate when it comes time to making cuts to specific programs and services,” the co-director of the poll, Eric Schickler said.

This article was originally published by CalMatters.

• Rural County Representatives of California Opposes AT&T Petition that Threatens Universal Telephone Service Protections
  Post Views: 12 If the FCC grants AT&T’s petition, the company could move forward with abandoning universal service obligations that millions of Californians rely on, particularly those living in rural communities. Broad coalition urges FCC to preserve California’s authority to protect access to reliable communications services for all residents SACRAMENTO, CA – The Rural County Representatives
• Obituary: Marjorie Elenore Rugg
  Post Views: 10 Marjorie Eleanore Rugg (Kinkead) was born June 18, 1930, in Yreka, California. Her birth mother, Margaret A. Pope, died soon after giving birth to Marjorie. She lived with her grandparents, Newton and Phoebe Kinkead, until 1935, when her Father, Seymour Kinkead, and his wife, Ruby May, took her back to live with
• Only 16 of California’s 109 Federally Recognized Tribes Have Quantified Water Rights, PPIC Report Finds
  Post Views: 29 Negotiated settlements offer clearest path to certainty for Tribes and other water users A new report from the Public Policy Institute of California examines the complex and often poorly understood system of Tribal water rights across the state, finding that just 16 of the 109 federally recognized Tribes have had their federal
• With Water Board funding, tribe to regain nearly 40,000 acres of ancestral lands in Klamath River Basin 
  Post Views: 181 Largest single land back deal will advance tribal water quality projects Source: State Water BoardJuly 24, 2026                                                                    SACRAMENTO –The State
• White House admits it used keywords to kill billions worth of California research grants
  Post Views: 24 By Mikhail Zinshteyn, CalMatters This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters. Federal agencies that terminated more than a thousand research grants at the University of California last year admitted that they used keywords related to diversity, gender, vaccine hesitancy and COVID-19 to screen for projects that ran